Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
○ Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Preprints posted in the last 90 days, ranked by how well they match Psychonomic Bulletin & Review's content profile, based on 14 papers previously published here. The average preprint has a 0.01% match score for this journal, so anything above that is already an above-average fit.
Claeys, W.; Ruuskanen, V.; Mathot, S.
Show abstract
When we feel restless and easily distracted, continuously switching tasks (exploration), our pupils tend to be large. In contrast, when we are calmly focused on a single task (exploitation), our pupils tend to be small. According to the Adaptive Gain Theory (AGT), a switch from exploitation to exploration is associated with an increase in norepinephrine in the locus coeruleus, which in turn triggers pupil dilation. However, the AGT does not provide a functional explanation of why exploration triggers pupil dilation. One possibility is that visual sensitivity, which increases with pupil size, is especially important during exploration. We set out to provide evidence consistent with this functional explanation, as well as to replicate two key previous results. Participants performed a four-armed bandit task, which induces both exploration and exploitation behavior. During the task, participants also needed to detect an occasional and unpredictable near-threshold peripheral flash. We replicated two key results: pupils were larger during exploration than during exploitation; and increased pupil size (overall, independent of exploration status) was associated with increased visual sensitivity. However, most importantly, we did not find that visual sensitivity was higher during exploration than during exploitation; probably, the reliable-yet-tiny increase in pupil size during exploration was too small to affect visual sensitivity. We conclude that key previous results are replicable; however, common experimental paradigms, such as the four-armed bandit task, induce only small changes in exploration behavior. Therefore, more powerful paradigms are required in order to test functional explanations of pupil-size changes during exploration and exploitation.
Haarlem, C. S.; Tiernan, J. G.; Kelly, M.; Cooney, L.; Jackson, A. L.; Mitchell, K. J.; McGovern, D. P.; O'Connell, R. G.
Show abstract
The critical flicker fusion (CFF) threshold is a psychophysical measure used to quantify the temporal resolution of the visual system and is known to vary across individuals. However, it is unclear if this measure is stimulus-specific, or if it may represent a more fundamental processing rate for visual perception in general. Here, we assess if individual variation in CFF is predictive of two features of visual processing that are dependent on temporal perception: the attentional blink and global motion sensitivity. In a non-clinical sample of 84 individuals, flicker fusion thresholds were predictive of the magnitude of the attentional blink. In contrast, we found no link between flicker fusion and global motion sensitivity in a sample of 79 individuals. Our results suggest that CFF reflects a visual processing rate that impacts other, more complex perceptual tasks.
Pesthy, O.; Toth-Faber, E.; Nagy, C.; Nemeth, M.; Janacsek, K.; Nemeth, D.
Show abstract
Children often outperform adults in probabilistic statistical learning tasks, yet the mechanisms underlying this developmental advantage remain poorly understood. Here, we used eye-tracking measures of belief updating to examine how children and adults acquire and update predictions in a probabilistic sequence-learning task. Using the standard (oculomotor) reaction time measure, children showed stronger statistical learning than adults, replicating previous behavioral findings while revealing a more detailed profile of developmental differences in statistical learning. Critically, children updated their predictions more frequently: they were less likely to repeat previous predictions and more likely to shift their expectations in response to new input. Adults, in contrast, showed greater persistence, tending to maintain prior predictions even when those predictions were inconsistent with the underlying statistical structure. Despite these pronounced differences in updating behavior, the processing and use of prediction errors were remarkably similar across age groups. These findings indicate that developmental differences in statistical learning do not primarily arise from how prediction errors are computed, but rather from how prior beliefs and incoming information are weighted during belief updating. Children's enhanced learning may therefore reflect reduced reliance on stable priors and greater sensitivity to current sensory evidence, supporting a more exploratory learning strategy. Adults, by contrast, appear to favor an exploitative strategy that stabilizes existing predictions but reduces flexibility in probabilistic environments. More broadly, the results suggest that developmental changes in statistical learning may reflect age-related differences in how readily learners revise their predictions in response to incoming evidence. By integrating sensitive oculomotor measures with analyses that probe the mechanisms underlying belief updating, the present study provides a more fine-grained account of how predictive learning changes across development and offers a framework for reconciling previously inconsistent developmental findings in statistical learning.
Callahan-Flintoft, C.; Larkin, G. B.
Show abstract
Visual search is a critical component of many professions such as military operations, baggage screening, and radiology. Aided Target Recognition (AiTR) systems are designed to highlight potential threats across the operator visual field in real-time, directing attention and improving accuracy. However, these systems may impact search and, consequently, situational awareness by diverting attentional resources from non-highlighted, yet relevant, locations. Previous work suggests that scene gist is extracted within the first 250 ms of scene onset (Vo & Henderson, 2010). As such, this study examined whether a 250 ms AiTR onset delay could encourage a more even distribution of attention. Participants searched synthetically generated scenes and classified each person in the scene as armed or unarmed. Depending on their condition, participants either saw the scenes unaugmented (No AiTR condition), with AiTR highlights consisting of red bounding boxes around armed people and yellow boxes around unarmed (AiTR condition), or with AiTR highlights presented 250 ms post scene onset (Delayed AiTR condition). A surprise memory test of background objects presented in the search scenes was administered to all participants upon completion of the search task. As predicted and preregistered, results showed less overt attentional deployment to background information (anything other than the people themselves) in the AiTR condition compared to No AiTR , however, decreased overt attentional deployment was not seen in the Delayed AiTR group. A similar pattern was observed in the memory data (with the AiTR condition having a lower score than the No AiTR condition and the Delayed AiTR condition), this difference was not significant.
Penaloza, B.; Maniglia, M.; Munneke, J.; Green, C. S.; Seitz, A.
Show abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the feasibility, validity, and scalability of PLFest, an open-source, Unity-based, cross-platform application designed for standardized, multi-site visual and cognitive assessment and training. Methods: Two hundred sixty participants (mean age = 23 years) were recruited across four university sites in the United States. Participants completed a battery of five visual assessments administered through PLFest, including visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, spatial frequency cutoff, contrast sensitivity at spatial-frequency cutoff, and visual search. Five cognitive assessments measuring visuospatial working memory, verbal working memory, fluid reasoning, inhibitory control, and selective attention were also administered. Descriptive statistics and performance distributions were examined and compared with normative data. Results: Visual acuity and contrast sensitivity measures closely matched previously reported normative values obtained using established clinical and psychophysical methods. Spatial frequency cutoff and visual search tasks produced stable threshold estimates while showing substantial inter-individual variability. Performance across all cognitive assessments was consistent with published validation studies of the corresponding tasks. Across the full battery, adaptive procedures demonstrated reliable convergence and generated well-distributed performance measures without evidence of substantial floor or ceiling effects. Importantly, these findings were observed across four geographically distributed testing sites using standardized consumer-grade tablet hardware. Conclusions: PLFest provides reliable and scalable assessment of visual and cognitive function using portable consumer devices. The platform supports standardized data collection across distributed research settings while maintaining performance characteristics consistent with established laboratory and clinical benchmarks. These findings support the use of PLFest as a reliable framework for large-scale studies of vision and cognition. Translational Relevance: By reducing dependence on specialized laboratory infrastructure and trained personnel, PLFest may facilitate broader access to visual and cognitive assessment, enabling large-scale research, screening, and future rehabilitation applications.
Andrade, K. D.; Melton, D. L.; Ries, S. K.
Show abstract
Language production requires the coordination of multiple cognitive processes. The ability to anticipate and override a habitual response in favor of a contextually-appropriate response are key subprocesses of cognitive control which enable speakers to communicate effectively. Word retrieval involves the co-activation of semantically related alternatives from which the speaker must select the appropriate target representation. Although cognitive control mechanisms have been proposed to contribute to resolving semantic interference during language production, the nature of these control processes remain unclear. Studies investigating the temporal dynamics of cognitive control during decision making tasks have led to a distinction between two operating processes: proactive control, initiated prior to the occurrence of conflict, and reactive control recruited after conflict is detected. We investigated the roles of proactive and reactive control in resolving interference between competing linguistic representations during word retrieval. We analyzed congruency sequence effects combined with delta-plot distributional analyses to dissociate potential adjustments in proactive versus reactive cognitive control in a picture-naming task manipulating semantic context compared to a minimally-linguistic Stroop-like paradigm. Reaction time distributional properties following semantically related trials revealed the engagement of proactive control in semantic interference resolution during word retrieval in the PWI task. In contrast, reactive inhibitory control was engaged in resolving semantic interference following low conflict trials. This distinction was not present in the minimally-linguistic task, which did not appear to engage adaptive control to the same extent. These findings demonstrate that both proactive and reactive cognitive control mechanisms contribute to language production, and are engaged dynamically, adjusting trial-by-trial to resolve semantic interference during word retrieval. In addition, our study provides important insight into the comparison of language with other cognitive domains and positions linguistic paradigms as being instrumental in the study of cognitive control dynamics.
Makhsous, M.; Jowkar, M.; Rezayat, E.
Show abstract
Studying chess experts helps researchers understand how intensive practice shapes thinking skills. Cognitive flexibility is the ability to adjust thoughts when rules or tasks change. Working memory is the ability to hold and use information over short periods. This study compared cognitive flexibility and working memory precision between adolescent chess players and non-players. Twenty-four professional chess players and twenty-five controls completed two novel behavioral tasks. Chess players showed better accuracy in both tasks than controls. They adapted more efficiently when rules changed during a continuous learning task. They also remembered facial expressions more precisely in a working memory task. Learning rates in the flexibility task did not differ between groups. These results indicate that chess expertise may improve rule-guided flexibility and visual working memory precision in adolescents.
Ruopp, R.; Williams, E. A.; Gach, M.; Baese-Berk, M.; Greenhouse, I.
Show abstract
Certain features of everyday motor skills become automatic while others remain controlled. Here we use a novel keyboard typing task to investigate whether motor automaticity depends on the frequency of naturally learned motor sequences. Participants type five-letter strings that vary in their word and bigram (two-letter sequence) frequency in natural language, allowing us to examine the influence of prior exposure without laboratory training. Novel pseudo word strings are tested as well. We find greater sequence frequency in natural language is associated with faster inter-keypress intervals and lower temporal variability within the sequence. In contrast, latencies to initiate a sequence are slower for novel pseudo-word strings but are otherwise insensitive to natural word frequency. We also find individual differences in inter-keypress speed and variability are robust across frequency levels but are unrelated to conventional measures of typing skill. Our method establishes keyboard typing as a scalable, ethologically valid framework for probing features of a naturally acquired human motor skill. This research will help extend laboratory-based studies of motor sequence learning and sets the stage for future investigations of linguo-motor processes. Moreover, our findings demonstrate which features within naturally acquired motor sequences become automatic and that typing proficiency is not determined solely by automaticity.
Lee, H.-H.; Carrasco, M.
Show abstract
Covert spatial attention selects and prioritizes relevant sensory information. Endogenous attention is voluntary, goal-driven, and flexible. However, it cannot alleviate visual polar-angle asymmetries, specifically, the horizontal-vertical anisotropy and the vertical meridian asymmetry. Visual perception is affected by both current sensory inputs and contextual information over time and space, such as the perception of preceding trials. Previous studies reported sequential effects whereby attention interacts with response repetitions. But it is unknown whether and how endogenous attention modulation on performance varies as a function of target location and trial history. Here, we reanalyzed data from three published studies of endogenous attention in orientation discrimination tasks, to (1) assess the typical sequential effects on response, in which response to the current trial is biased toward the previous one, and (2) examine if sequential effects would modulate the performance across locations, across four dimensions: (1) location, (2) feature, (3) attention repetition condition, and (4) the correctness of the preceding (n -1) trial. First, we demonstrated typical sequential effects of response repetition to the repeated location and feature aspects of the target. Second, we found a robust effect of attention on performance, but the results did not reveal evidence of sequential attention effects as a function of the four dimensions in any of the three studies. Moreover, there were no interactions between attention and location when considering trial history. Together, these findings provide compelling evidence that visual polar-angle asymmetries are resistant to endogenous attention, and that even top- down factors-sequential effects-do not alleviate these asymmetries in performance.
Zimmermann Bortoluzzi, L.; Rohenkohl, G.
Show abstract
During active vision, the brain must coordinate where to move the eyes with predictions about upcoming sensory input. Before each saccade, perception is enhanced at the upcoming fixation location, but whether this enhancement depends on expectations about target features remains unknown. Here, participants prepared a saccade to a cued location while reporting the presence and orientation of a brief visual target that appeared either at the saccade goal or at the opposite location. Feature expectation was manipulated across blocks by varying the probability of the two target orientations. Perceptual sensitivity (d') increased when targets were presented at the saccade goal, consistent with presaccadic enhancement, and was also higher for less expected features. However, these effects were independent: feature probability did not alter the magnitude of presaccadic enhancement. Moreover, presaccadic enhancement increased near saccade onset, whereas the advantage for less expected features weakened as movement onset approached. Saccade latency revealed a contrasting pattern. Visual targets presented at the saccade goal delayed movement initiation. This delay depended on feature probability, with longer latencies for unexpected than for expected features only when saccades were directed towards the target. This location-specific effect persisted after accounting for perceptual report, and the latency cost for unexpected features was reproduced in a follow-up experiment. Together, these findings show that feature probability enhanced sensitivity to unexpected information independently of presaccadic enhancement, while selectively delaying saccade initiation towards targets with unexpected features. This dissociation suggests that feature expectation modulates perception and action through functionally distinct forms of visual processing.
Herrmann, B.; Fink, L. K.; Pandey, P. R.; Johnsrude, I.; Ryan, J. D.
Show abstract
Speech comprehension in noisy environments often requires cognitive effort, but listeners may disengage when comprehension becomes impossible. Eye movements have recently emerged as a promising new measure of listening effort, but it remains unclear whether eye movements are sensitive to the full effort profile across easy, difficult, and impossible speech comprehension. Across four experiments, participants listened to sentences at easy, difficult, and impossible levels of multi-talker background babble while pupil size and eye movements were recorded. Pupil size generally followed the expected inverted u-shaped effort profile: low for easy speech, maximal for difficult but still intelligible speech and lower again for impossible speech, although this pattern partly reflected sustained, condition-specific differences and not only sentence-evoked responses. Gaze dispersion - measuring the spread of eye movements - decreased with high temporal selectivity during difficult relative to easy and impossible speech, indicating reduced eye movements during active, effortful listening. However, gaze dispersion was also lower, but less temporally selective, during impossible compared to easy listening, especially in non-baseline-corrected analyses, suggesting that reduced eye movements do not index listening effort uniquely. Instead, eye movements appear to reflect both attentional engagement during difficult listening and disengagement or inward attention when meaningful listening is no longer possible. These findings indicate that pupil size and eye movements provide complementary indices of listening-related cognition, and highlight the integration of listening, cognition, and motor systems.
Jiwa, M.; Myles, D.; Bennett, D.
Show abstract
Recent research has suggested that the availability of non-instrumental information about the outcome of a risky choice increases risk appetite. In this study, we aimed to perform a conceptual replication of these findings and to examine the cognitive mechanisms underlying this effect. Across two experiments (N = 150, 102), we presented participants with mathematically fair gambles and allowed them to choose the size of their bet. Between trials, we varied the presence of non-instrumental information that would reveal the outcome ahead of time. In both experiments, we did not find consistent evidence for an effect of the availability of non-instrumental information on bet size. These findings suggest that the previously reported effects of non-instrumental information on risk appetite may have been an idiosyncratic feature of experimental design, rather than a more general phenomenon that characterises human decision making under risk.
Jörges, B.; Kim, J.-J.; Harris, L. R.
Show abstract
Continuous Psychophysics, which couples a continuous stimulus with a continuous response, is a promising tool to break out of the confines of traditional designs based on discrete trials. In this pre-registered study, we explore to what extent this paradigm is useful in the study of multisensory integration. We expand on Tonelli et al.s (2025) seminal study by additionally examining the role of eye-movements, using a Kalman filter to estimate the sensory noise underlying behavioral tracking parameters and employing a virtual reality set-up. We immersed two cohorts of participants (n = 30 each) in a virtual meadow environment and asked them to continuously track a drone (Experiment 1) or a swarm of flies (Experiment 2) with a controller, while simultaneously recording their eye movements. We manipulated the reliability of visual cues using four levels of fog (from a completely clear view to impenetrable fog where no visual cues to the targets position were available) as well as the presence of sound cues emitted from the object (sound present/absent). The maximum correlation between stimulus and response was higher when sound was present in some conditions, particularly when visual uncertainty was high, while the tracking delay remained unaffected across all fog levels. Using a Kalman filter to estimate the underlying sensory noise, we found strong evidence that sensory noise was lower when sound was present than when sound was absent both for manual and for ocular tracking, particularly for those conditions with higher visual uncertainty. In exploratory analyses, we further show strong correlations between manual and ocular tracking in all measures (maximum correlation, tracking delay, sensory precision). However, when isolating the multisensory advantage, these correlations all but disappeared for maximum correlation and tracking delay, while remaining substantial for sensory precision. Similarly, behavioral tracking correlated generally strongly with underlying sensory noise, but much less so when it came to the advantage conferred by added sound cues. Our results show that continuous psychophysics is well-suited for the study of multisensory integration, particularly when a Kalman filter analysis is used to estimate sensory uncertainty from behavioral data.
Teng, J.; Ekstrom, A. D.; Isham, E. A.
Show abstract
Learning to accurately estimate temporal intervals and spatial magnitudes is important to everyday behavior, yet few studies have directly compared how learning unfolds across these domains. Theoretical models of temporal interval estimation provide conflicting accounts of how this learning process might occur and how it might differ from other entities like spatial line estimation. In the present study, participants completed temporal interval and line-length production tasks under feedback or no-feedback conditions during a training phase. They were then tested without feedback and subsequently presented with untrained temporal intervals and line lengths to examine whether learning generalized to novel magnitudes. We found that both temporal and spatial production exhibited similar learning trajectories, characterized by rapid initial improvements, followed by asymptotic performance. Despite similar learning trajectories, however, spatial production reached higher levels of accuracy and precision faster and in a more sustained manner than temporal production. Feedback facilitated learning in both domains, with improvements in precision emerging early during training and improvements in accuracy becoming evident during the subsequent test phase. These benefits persisted into the transfer phase, particularly for spatial production, indicating that feedback-supported learning generalized to untrained magnitudes. Transfer performance also reflected systematic biases in magnitude estimation, consistent with a central tendency effect, with shorter magnitudes tending to be overproduced and longer magnitudes underestimated. Together, these findings demonstrate that temporal and spatial magnitude learning share some common and some dissociable learning dynamics, providing new insight into the shared and distinct mechanisms underlying magnitude learning and highlighting the important role of feedback in promoting learning and transfer.
Chen, S.; Mueller, H. J.; Shi, Z.
Show abstract
Attentional control balances proactive suppression of predictable distractors with reactive suppression of unexpected ones. Yet, how internal states such as alertness shape this balance is unclear. Using pupillometry and eye tracking across two probability-cueing experiments (conducted in 2024) with varying distractor prevalence, we distinguished tonic (baseline pupil size across blocks) from trial-level pupil size fluctuations (trial-by-trial residual variability in pre-stimulus pupil size). With moderate prevalence, suppression of frequent-region distractors developed gradually, whereas high prevalence induced near-immediate suppression. Behavioral measures (e.g., reaction times) were closely linked to tonic and trial-level pupil size fluctuations. Critically, both alertness components jointly influenced control: during early learning, heightened trial-level pupil size increased distractor capture and reduced target fixations, whereas later on, suppression shifted to a proactive mode resilient to trial-level fluctuations. Under high prevalence, this shift occurred faster. Notably, higher trial-level pupil size generally accelerated first target selection. These findings show that tonic alertness and trial-level alertness fluctuations dynamically regulate reactive and proactive control during statistical learning. Impact StatementThis study shows that people become better at ignoring predictable distractions over time, but that this improvement depends not only on what they have learned about the task environment, but also on their current level of alertness. By combining eye tracking and pupil measures, we found that temporary increases in alertness can sometimes help people orient more quickly to relevant information, yet during earlier stages of learning they can also make attention more vulnerable to distracting events. These findings suggest that successful focus in complex environments depends on a dynamic interplay between learned expectations and moment-to-moment fluctuations in mental state, with implications for understanding sustained attention in settings such as monitoring, driving, and other tasks that require people to stay engaged while resisting distraction.
Houdoyer, E.; Le Bars, S.; Chambon, V.
Show abstract
Automation has been shown to weaken the sense of agency (SoA), the experience of controlling ones actions and their outcomes, by disrupting the predictive link between intention and effect. Explainable AI (XAI) has been proposed as a solution, yet the neurocognitive mechanisms through which explanations restore agency remain unclear. Across three EEG experiments using an autonomous-driving paradigm, we examined how automation and different forms of AI explanations modulate explicit agency judgments and early neural markers of agency-related predictive processing. In Experiment 1, automation reduced explicit feelings of control and was associated with reduced sensory attenuation, as reflected by increased P1-N1 amplitudes, decreased N1-P2 amplitudes, and delayed N1 latencies. In Experiment 2, distal (goal-level) explanations partially restored agency and selectively modulated early auditory responses, decreasing P1-N1 and increasing N1-P2 amplitudes. In Experiment 3, combining distal and proximal (trajectory-level) explanations produced the strongest behavioural and neural restoration of agency, yielding a graded attenuation of P1-N1 and enhanced N1-P2 responses along with accelerated N1 latencies. Across all experiments, mismatch negativity (MMN) remained unaffected, indicating that pre-attentive deviance detection is preserved regardless of agency or explainability. Together, these results identify component-specific EEG markers that track fluctuations in the sense of agency and demonstrate that multi-level intention sharing by AI systems enhances both predictive engagement and explicit control experience. This work provides a neurocognitive foundation for designing explainable autonomous systems capable of maintaining user agency.
Malik, A.; Kolmel, L.; Billino, J.; Doerschner, K.
Show abstract
Humans rely on multiple sensory modalities, such as vision, audition, and touch, to perceive materials in everyday life. Previous research shows that multisensory perception leads to facilitation, yet the mechanisms responsible for this facilitation remain poorly understood. One potential mechanism is crossmodal prediction, whereby input from one modality generates predictions about another. While substantial research on multisensory facilitation has focused on bottom-up processes, such as spatial, temporal, and semantic congruency, the role of crossmodal predictions, particularly in material perception, has received little attention. To address this gap, we conducted two experiments, a reaction time task and a material rating task, in which participants viewed computer-generated animations of familiar objects being dropped to the ground. The paradigm exploited the natural temporal structure of impact events: pre-impact visual appearance provides information about an objects material and therefore can generate expectations about the forthcoming impact sound. Critically, participants saw the event only until before the impact, after which the video was masked. Thus, vision and audition were temporally aligned but not presented concurrently, allowing us to isolate the influence of visually driven expectations on the incoming auditory information without a bottom-up conflict. In some trials, the sound matched the expected material, but in a subset, it was incongruent, violating expectations elicited by the preceding visual information. Across both experiments, participants took longer to respond on incongruent than congruent trials, suggesting increased processing demands. In the rating task, incongruent trials also shifted material judgments, such that ratings reflected a weighted combination of incoming auditory information and visually driven predictions, with large individual differences in relative cue weighting. These findings suggest that priors on material properties from one modality, specifically vision, not only establish high-level expectations within the modality about an objects future state, but also extend across modalities.
Ruuskanen, V.; Mathot, S.
Show abstract
Prestimulus pupil size is associated with near-threshold detection performance in both the visual and auditory domain, a relationship that is commonly attributed to arousal. However, given that larger pupils also let more light into the eye, in the visual domain this relationship is likely also driven by optical effects. To better understand this, we investigated how pupil size, skin conductance, and electroencephalographic (EEG) measures relate to detection performance in both a visual and an auditory task. We found that larger pupils were associated with higher sensitivity in the visual condition but lower sensitivity in the auditory condition. Skin conductance was negatively related to visual sensitivity, but unrelated to auditory sensitivity. EEG power measures were not related to sensitivity in either condition, though pupil size was positively correlated with alpha and beta power. Together, these results suggest that in visual detection the relationship between pupil size and performance is driven by both arousal and optics, whereas in auditory detection the relationship is driven solely by arousal. More broadly, our findings highlight the pupil as an active and functional component of the visual system.
Kaltenmaier, A.; Press, C.
Show abstract
Past sensory experience shapes our perceptual decision-making in the now. Popular models frame perceptual decisions as either attracted towards or repelled away from recent sensory information, but it is unclear when and why these distinct effects emerge. We here ask whether effects turn from attractive to repulsive depending on the level of surprise elicited by the precision-weighted discrepancy between past and present sensory states. This model is based upon the idea that attraction is adaptive for optimizing efficiency and accuracy when discrepancies are small, because they likely reflect sensory noise rather than real change in the environment. In contrast, repulsion may reflect the upweighting of counterfactual evidence when discrepancies are large because they more likely signal the need for model updating. We test this model on a large amount of recently-collated trial-by-trial serial dependence data and consistently find support for it across the dataset, participant, and trial-by-trial level. Specifically, serial dependence effects are attractive at low discrepancies between past and current sensory states but turn repulsive when discrepancies are larger. Higher sensory precision is found to accelerate this flip by reducing the modal discrepancy threshold required to trigger repulsion effects. We discuss how these findings necessitate extending existing theories of serial dependence, and how they may resolve conflicts in the broader predictive processing, learning and perception literatures.
Simpson, N.; Rittershofer, K.; Ward, E. K.; Mazor, M.; Press, C.
Show abstract
Perception is typically biased towards prior expectations. In some cases, however, it seems repelled away from expectations, such that percepts appear less like what is expected. Even more intriguingly, separate studies have recently reported that predictions derived from gravity may shape perception in opposing ways. Specifically, gravity causes unsupported objects to accelerate downwards, leading to two predictions; that objects will move downwards (location prior) and at an increasing speed (acceleration prior). There is evidence that perceptual judgements are attracted towards location priors yet repelled from acceleration ones. Here we examine these effects in the same paradigm to determine whether they result from different types of stimuli and judgement, or more interestingly, might result from opposite influences of common predictive mechanisms influencing perception. We first replicate previous reports of a systematic bias to report upward moving objects as more accelerating than downward moving objects: effectively a repulsion from acceleration priors. We then show that the effect applies both at the level of retinal space and due to contextual cues concerning gravitational direction. Finally, we find that participants errors in a location reproduction task are similarly consistent with a repulsion from acceleration priors and, simultaneously, with an attraction towards location priors. We conclude by considering the ways in which these concurrent attractive and repulsive biases may reflect mechanisms optimising fast, accurate, and informative experiences in our ever-changing sensory world, therefore optimising the interface between perception and learning. Public Significance StatementIn a series of behavioural experiments, we show that expectations about how objects move due to gravity concurrently attract perception towards the prediction that objects move downwards, and repel perception away from the prediction that they do so at an increasing rate. These opposing influences inform current theories of perceptual processing, which explain how expectations may generate percepts that are fast, veridical, and informative.